A solution in search of a problem: on
Mains Paper 2: Governance
Prelims level: Economically weaker sections
Mains level: Welfare schemes for the vulnerable sections
- The recently passed Constitution (124th Amendment) Bill, 2019,
creating a 10% quota for the economically weaker sections (EWS), will serve
as anything more than a band-aid.
- Given the deep inequalities prevalent in access to education and
jobs based on caste and socio-economic status, affirmative action (or
positive discrimination) makes a lot of sense.
- The system that was put in place during the early years of the
Republic deserves serious re-evaluation in an era when technology has paved
the way for deploying a better equipped arsenal.
Excluding no one
- The Bill promises 10% reservation to individuals classified as
- However, while a number of criteria were discussed in the
parliamentary debate, the Bill is quite silent on this.
- Assuming that among the criteria discussed in Parliament, those
that are currently applied to the definition of the Other Backward Classes (OBC)
creamy layer are the ones to be used, it is not clear how useful they would
- While the OBC creamy layer has been created to exclude people who
are clearly well off, the EWS quota, in contrast, is expected to focus on
- One of the criteria the income threshold of ₹8 lakh per annum has
been mentioned. The National Sample Survey (NSS) of 2011-12 shows that the
annual per capita expenditure for 99% of households falls under this
threshold, even when we take inflation into account.
- Similarly, as per the India Human Development Survey (IHDS), the
annual household incomes of 98% of households are less than ₹8 lakh. Even if
we apply all the other criteria for exclusion (e.g. amount of land owned and
size of home), the Bill would still cover over 95% of the households. So,
who are we excluding?
Limiting the reservation for other categories
- The benefits of the EWS quota are likely to be minimal, the cost
may be higher than one anticipates.
- It is important to remember that general category jobs are open to
everyone, including Scheduled Caste (SC), Scheduled Tribe (ST) and OBC
- Thus, by removing 10% jobs from the “open” category, it reduces
the opportunities for currently reserved groups.
- This may be particularly problematic for OBCs since OBC
reservation is limited to 27% of the seats whereas the OBC population is at
least 40% of the population, possibly more.
- This move is almost certain to result in calls for greater OBC
reservation, particularly if a constitutional amendment to increase the
proportion of reserved seats from 50% to 60% is already being adopted.
Getting caste certificates
- Actual implementation of the EWS quota could be challenging.
- Few non-SC/ST/OBC individuals have a caste certificate.
- A large number of SC/ST/OBC households report difficulties in
obtaining these certificates.
Economic development challenges
- In an era when skill demands are rapidly outpacing supply of
candidates in specialised fields, the EWS quota increases the constraints.
- If a university advertises for an associate professor for quantum
physics under the EWS quota and the only suitable candidate happens to be
from an OBC category, she could not be hired.
- These challenges occur for all positions under specifically
reserved categories and we have chosen to live with these difficulties in
the interest of the greater good of equity.
- However, there is little benefit to be derived from the EWS quota.
- The greatest cost of this amendment lies in the foregone
opportunity to develop an enhanced and more effective reservation policy so
that we can genuinely see an end to the entrenched inequalities in Indian
society in the medium term.
- We have gotten so used to business as usual that we make no effort
to sharpen our focus and look for more effective solutions, solutions that
would make reservations redundant in 50 years.
- If we were to redesign from scratch, what would an effective
affirmative action policy look like?
- If the goal is to help as many people as possible, we are facing a
- On the one hand, 50% reservation looks very large; in the grand
scheme of India’s population it is a blunt and at times ineffective
Spread the benefits
- One strategy may be to try and spread the benefits of reservations
as widely as possible within the existing framework and ensure that
individuals use their reserved category status only once in their lifetime.
- This would require that anyone using reservations to obtain a
benefit such as college admission must register his/her Aadhaar number and
she would be ineligible to use reservations for another benefit (e.g. a job)
in the future.
- This would require no changes to the basic framework but spread
the benefits more broadly within the reserved category allowing a larger
number of families to seek upward mobility.
- A second strategy might be to recognise that future economic
growth in India is going to come from the private sector and
- In order to ensure that all Indians, regardless of caste, class
and religion, are able to partake in economic growth, we must focus on basic
- We have focused on admission to prestigious colleges and
government jobs, but little attention is directed to social inequality in
the quality of elementary schooling.
- The IHDS shows that among children aged 8-11, 68% of the forward
caste children can read at Class 1 level while the proportion is far lower
for OBCs (56%), SCs (45%) and STs (40%).
- This suggests that we need to focus on reducing inequalities where
they first emerge, within primary schools.
- The challenge we face is that our mindset is so driven by the
reservation system that was developed in a different era that we have not
had the time or the inclination to think about its success or to examine
- The tragedy of the EWC quota is that it detracts from this
Q.1) In case of a Money Bill, the Rajya Sabha can
1. Approve the Bill
2. Make amendments to the Bill
3. Reject the Bill
Select the correct code
a) 1 Only
b) 1 and 2 Only
c) 2 and 3 Only
d) 1 and 3 Only
Q.1) Instead of addressing inequality, the 10% quota for economically
weaker sections creates huge anxieties. Give your arguments in this regard of