Rights, revised: on the Transgender Persons Bill, 2018

Mains Paper 1: Polity
Prelims level: Transgender Persons Bill
Mains level: Welfare schemes for vulnerable sections of the population

Context

•  The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill, 2018, as passed, is an improved version of the legislation introduced two years ago.
•  The earlier draft was widely perceived as falling short of the expectations of stakeholders and not adequately rights-based, as envisaged by the Supreme Court in its landmark decision on transgender rights in 2014.
•  Experts, as well as the Standing Committee of Parliament on Social Justice and Empowerment, had criticised the original definition of ‘transgender persons’ for violating the right to self determined identity.

Revised definition

•  The revised definition omits the reference to a ‘neither male nor female’ formulation, and covers any person whose gender does not match the gender assigned at birth, as well as transmen, transwomen, those with intersex variations, the gender-queer, and those who designate themselves based on socio-cultural identities such as hijra, aravani, kinner and jogta.
•  The requirement that a district screening committee must recommend the issue of a certificate to each transgender may be necessary to prevent misuse, but such a process goes against the principle of self-identification, a key right the Supreme Court had protected.
•  The government has omitted the need to go through the same screening committee to get a revised certificate after a transgender has sex reassignment surgery, but the medical certification requirement remains.
•  Transgender persons may question the need for such external gate-keeping.

Major concerns highlighted in this bill

•  There are other legitimate concerns in the revised Bill, which will now go to the Rajya Sabha.
•  One refers to the bar on forcible separation of transgender persons from their families, except through court orders.
•  It has been revised to cover transgender children.
•  Earlier it covered adults as well, but the committee had noted that it was within the family that many transgender persons faced harassment and abuse, and often felt driven to flee their homes.
•  Another concern is that the Bill criminalises begging by making it an offence for someone to compel or entice a transgender person into seeking alms.
•  When begging itself is no more seen as an offence, it may harm the community if such a means of livelihood in the absence of employment is criminalised.

Way forward

•  The Bill, unfortunately, does not give effect to the far-reaching directive of the Supreme Court to grant backward class reservation to the transgender community.
•  The Standing Committee’s doesn’t concerns about recognising civil rights in marriage, divorce and adoption among them been addressed.
•  There is much good intention behind the welfare provisions, but social legislation is much more than high-minded clauses.
•  It needs to be followed up with zealous implementation and framing of deadlines to achieve specific objectives.

Online Coaching for UPSC PRE Exam

General Studies Pre. Cum Mains Study Materials

Prelims Questions:

Q.1) The Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014 passed by Rajya Sabha entitles the transgender to
1. Reservations in education and jobs
2. Unemployment allowances and provision for skill development
3. Reservation in certain electoral constituencies as a pilot initiative

Select the correct answer using the codes below.
a) 1 and 2 only
b) 2 and 3 only
c) 1 only
d) 1, 2 and 3 only

Answer: A

Mains Questions:
Q.1) What are the major highlights in the newly passed bill to protect transgender persons, but concerns remain?