SELECTED ARTICLES FROM VARIOUS NEWSPAPERS & JOURNALS
(April + May 2014)
Telangana birth-pangs
By getting a resolution rejecting the Andhra Pradesh
Reorganisation Bill for creating Telangana passed by the State Assembly just
before the deadline set by President Pranab Mukherjee to consider the Bill ended
on Thursday, Chief Minister N. Kiran Kumar Reddy did what little he could to
protect what he saw as his political constituency: those standing for a united
Andhra Pradesh in the Rayalaseema and Coastal Andhra regions. Neither the delay
nor the ultimate rejection of the Telangana Bill by the Assembly will have any
bearing on the creation of the new State if the Centre stands firm on its
decision on Telangana. The Chief Minister, in raising legal and technical
objections to the Bill, might have managed to convey the opposition of large
sections of the people in Seemandhra to the division of Andhra Pradesh, but the
manner in which the proceedings of the House were conducted from the day the
Bill was introduced till the day it was rejected reflects badly on his
government and the democratic traditions of the legislature. Speaker Nadendla
Manohar, who too is politically opposed to Telangana, put the Chief Minister’s
contentious resolution to a voice vote amid noisy scenes, and declared the
motion carried in a matter of two minutes. It was obvious from the regional
representation in the House that those opposed to the Bill constituted a
majority. The Bill presented a chance to address the concerns raised by the
proposal to bifurcate Andhra Pradesh. Instead, the time was used for political
posturing and the reiteration of known positions by both sides. Pro- Telangana
members, on their part, did not press for a division amid the din, perhaps
because they did not want to expose their lack of numbers. The voice vote was,
in effect, the only mode of expression of the views of the legislature.
Now that the onus is on the Centre to shepherd the Bill
through Parliament, the Congress must eschew any temptation to use this issue as
part of any electoral strategy before the Lok Sabha polls. With the national
leadership of the party backing the creation of Telangana, and the State unit
divided on geographical lines, making this a campaign issue is anyway fraught
with risks. No political consensus on the Bill is possible at this late stage,
but the Centre can bring in amendments to the Bill to incorporate the concerns
of other parties and representatives of Rayalaseema and Coastal Andhra. As the
support of the Bharatiya Janata Party is necessary in the Rajya Sabha, the
Congress will have to keep the Bill open for amendments. The State legislature
was robbed of a free, reasoned debate on the issue, but hopefully Parliament
will consider all aspects of the Bill before bringing Telangana into being.