THE GIST of Editorial for UPSC Exams : 20 October 2020 Still awaiting police reform (The Hindu)


Still awaiting police reform (The Hindu)

Mains Paper 3: Security 
Prelims level: Police reform 
Mains level: Security forces and agencies and their mandate


  • Police brutality in recent months has turned quotidian.
  • The thrashing of a Dalit Ahirwar couple by the police in Guna district of Madhya Pradesh on July 14 was very distressing.
  • But for the media coverage, the incident would have gone unnoticed.
  • The District Collector and the Superintendent of Police have been transferred and six police personnel have been suspended since the incident.
  • The matter will soon be forgotten.

Remedial measures:

  • The public outcry following the brutal torture of J. Benicks and his father P. Jayaraj in Thoothkudi district of TN resulting in their death had still not died when news came that a gangster, Vikas Dubey, was killed by the UP police in Kanpur when he allegedly tried to flee from custody.
  • The police version of the incident was quite unbelievable. It looked like the law had been subverted.
  • These incidents and several others show that we need immediate remedial measures lest the country witnesses an upheavalof the kind that the U.S. saw following the death of George Floyd.
  • Should such a situation arise, it will be the political class that will squarely be held responsible.
  • Political class have been the stumbling block in the implementation of various apex court directives aimed at improving the functioning of the police.

 Solutions that remain on paper:

  • Commissions and committees are set up every time there are demands for police reforms after a major incident.
  • Then the recommendations of such commissions and committees are simply consigned to the archives.
  • But they are not forgotten as some senior police officials vociferously demand implementation of their recommendations from time to time.
  • The first serious attempt to overhaul the policing machinery was made when the National Police Commission (NPC) was set up in 1977.
  • The NPC submitted eight reports to the Ministry of Home Affairs between 1979 and 1981.
  • Seven of these reports were circulated to the States in 1983 with an annotation that “the Commission has been unduly critical of the political system or the functioning of the police force in general”.
  • In a subtle manner, a signal had been sent.
  • The report was put in cold storage until Prakash Singh, a retired IPS officer, filed a PIL in the apex court in 1996 demanding the implementation of the NPC’s recommendations.
  • In 2006, the Supreme Court issued a slewof directives on police reform.
  • These would have had a far-reaching impact had the States and the Centre paid any serious attention to them.
  • But that would have upset the applecart of our politicians and even the bureaucrats, some of whom are known to be corrupt and mired in crime.
  • According to a report by the Association for Democratic Reforms (2018), there were 1,580 MPs and MLAs facing criminal charges.
  • Therein lies the crux of the matter.

Turning a blind eye:

  • The one diktat that would hurt the most is the setting up of a State Security Commission (SSC) in each State which would divest the political leaders of the unbridled power that they wield at present.
  • Of the States that constituted an SSC, only Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka have made SSC recommendations binding on the State government, according to the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative.
  • Only six States provided a minimum tenure of two years to the Director General of Police (DGP).
  • In Tamil Nadu, T.K. Rajendran, who was made DGP (Intelligence) and given full additional charge as DGP in September 2016, was formally appointed DGP on the day he attained the age of superannuation.
  • Many States have not implemented a single directive of the Supreme Court.


  • Since expecting political will to implement police reforms is a far cry, it is for the judiciary to step in and enforce the diktats it had passed.
  • Fourteen years is too long a period for any further relaxation.
  • The Court has to come down heavily on the States and the Centre to ensure that its directives are not dismissed lightly.
  • A bold step towards bringing down crimes is possible only when the politicians-criminals-police nexus is strangled.

Online Coaching for UPSC PRE Exam

E-Books Download for UPSC IAS Exams

General Studies Pre. Cum Mains Study Material

Prelims Questions:

Q.1)With reference to the Air Force Day, consider the following statements:
1. The Indian Air Force celebrated the 88th Air Force Day on October 8.
2. October 8 is celebrated as the Air Force Day because on this day, the Air Force in India was officially raised in 1932 as the supporting force of the Royal Air Force of the United Kingdom.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) Both 1 and 2
(d) Neither 1 nor 2

Answer: C

Mains Questions:

Q.1)What are Police Reforms? What arse the need for Police Reforms? What are the guidelines by the Supreme Court in 2006 regarding police reforms in India?