Sample Material of Our IAS Mains GS Online Coaching Programme
Subject: General Studies (Paper 2 - Governance, Constitution, Polity, Social Justice and International relations)
Topic: Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of
SOURCE OF INDIAN CONSTITUTION
It is on this account that the Constitution of India is regarded as a bag of
borrowings. However, only those principles were borrowed which could serve well
the Indian circumstances and aspirations. There was no blind borrowing.
1. British Constitution : The British Constitution (Mother Constitution) had its
impact in the following respects:
( i ) Constitutional head of State,
House of Parliament (Lok Sabha) is more powerful than the Upper House,
Responsibility of Council of Ministers to Parliament,
(iv) Parliamentary system
(v) Prevalence of Rule of Law.
2.U.S. Constitution : The Constitution of the United States had its impact in
the following respects :
(i) Preamble of the Constitution,
(ii) Provision of
(iii) Functions of the Vice-President,
(iv) Amendment of the
(v) Nature and functions of the Supreme Court,
3.Australian Constitution : Australian Constitution gave us a long list of
concurrent powers and the procedure for solving deadlock over concurrent
subjects between the Centre and the States.
4.Irish Constitution: The Irish Constitution gave us the Directive Principles of
State Policy and the method of nominating members of the Rajya Sabha.
5.Weimar Constitution of Germany : The Weimar Constitution of Germany had its
impact upon the powers of the President.
6.Canadian Constitution :We borrowed the provision of a strong nation, the name
‘Union’ of India and vesting residuary powers with the Union from Canada.
7. South African Constitution : The procedure of amendment with a two-thirds
majority in Parliament and the election of the members of the Rajya Sabha on the
basis of proportional representation by the State legislatures have been
borrowed from the Constitution of South Africa.
1. Indian federation is not the result of an agreement between States.
2. There is only one citizenship for both the
States and Union.
3. Each State sends M.P.s to the Parliament depending upon the population of the
4. There is no principle of quality between the states.
5. There are three Lists- Union List-(First List); State List (Second List); and
Concurrent List- (Third List). The Parliament can legislate only the subjects of
the State List and Concurrent List. The States are not sovereign. The Union can
encroach upon State’s Lists.
6. No State can separate from Indian Territory.
7. The Parliament, i.e. Center has been residuary powers.
8. There is only one Constitution for Union and States.
9. India achieved uniformity in basic civil and criminal laws, except’ personal
laws in some matters.
10. The Indian Union is an indestructible Union of destructible States. The
area, identity of a state can be changed by Parliament. The State scan be
destructible. But the Union can not be changed. The Union is indestructible.
11. The Central Government has been the power to form a new State, to increase
the area of any State, to diminish the area of any State; to alter the
boundaries of any State; to alter the name of any State; and to form a new State
by separation of territory from any State or by uniting two or more -States or
parts of States or by uniting any territory to a partnership the of any State
12. The word “Federal” is not at all used in our Constitution. Simply the
framers described “Union”.