GS Mains Model Question & Answer: Do you think India’s conflict with Pakistan could mean a greater role for Delhi in Kabul ? Give your arguments


GS Mains Model Question & Answer: Do you think India’s conflict with Pakistan could mean a greater role for Delhi in Kabul ? Give your arguments.


Q. Do you think India’s conflict with Pakistan could mean a greater role for Delhi in Kabul ? Give your arguments. (12.5 Marks)

(General Studies Mains Paper II – International relations: India and its neighborhood- relations)

Model Answer :

The ouster of the Taliban at the end of 2001, Delhi has tended to plough a lonely furrow. Its emphasis was on economic assistance. The Western countries, noting Pakistan’s objections, discouraged India from seeking a larger security role in Afghanistan.

  • In the new and regional phase, India is bound to be drawn more deeply into the Afghan conflict. With India’s relations with Pakistan entering a period of turbulence, Afghanistan could acquire an unusual prominence in India’s regional strategy.

  • India’s own new significance in Afghanistan’s politics is reflected in the recent American decision to resume the trilateral consultations with Delhi and Kabul. Unlike in the past, Washington is urging Delhi to step up military support to Kabul. India and Afghanistan are also involved in trilateral cooperation with Iran.

  • Ashraf Ghani’s diplomatic support for India on pulling out of the South Asian Summit in Islamabad is a shift from Kabul’s traditional reluctance to be drawn into the India-Pak disputes.

  • In the recent past, Delhi’s engagement with Kabul was also limited by Delhi’s hopes for a normalisation of relations with Islamabad. Those hopes have receded for now and created conditions for fresh Indian thinking on the relationship with Afghanistan.

  • Developments in the Kabul valley have always been consequential for the empires centred on the Yamuna. But Delhi was tied down by the “Panipat syndrome” — the inability to look beyond its nose and anticipate the gathering challenges. By eliminating the physical border with Afghanistan, the Partition further reduced Kabul’s salience in Delhi’s strategic calculus. Now, with the widening arc of India’s conflict with Pakistan, Afghanistan is likely to loom larger than ever before for India.

  • As India’s power in Afghanistan expands, especially its soft power, Pakistan is losing its position of economic and strategic privilege. In its place is a power with possibly hostile intentions against it. For example, India’s reconstruction and development projects through Afghanistan’s Pashtun belt are seen as ways of fomenting separatist movements in Pakistan.

  • Pakistan sees India’s growing influence, particularly its consular presence in Afghanistan, as a threat. Islamabad believes that India is colluding with Afghan officials to stoke Baloch separatism in Pakistan.

References:

If you are facing problem in General Studies Mains preparation call at +91 7827687693

Join General Studies Test Series for IAS Mains Examination

Buy Printed Study Kit for IAS Mains GS Exam

Buy Study Kit on Current Affairs for UPSC Mains Examination

Join Online IAS Coaching for General Studies Mains

<< Go Back to Main Page